Search results
Query: SWR myths
Links: 4 | Categories: 0
-
This resource details the conversion of an 80m elevated vertical antenna to include 160m operation, focusing on a relay-switched design over a trap-based approach. It presents specific feedpoint impedance values, such as **32 ohms** for 80m and **14 ohms** for 160m, and discusses the challenges of SWR drift encountered with the prior trap system during RTTY contesting. The article thoroughly explains the design choices for elevated radials, referencing _N6LF QEX data_ to debunk common myths regarding radial length and height, demonstrating that non-resonant radials can offer superior current uniformity. The construction section provides practical insights into building the vertical, including guying strategies, material selection from scrap pipe, and weatherproofing the relay assembly. It highlights the use of a common mode choke for the relay switching line, measuring approximately 5K ohms on both 160m and 80m, and details the L/C matching network's role in achieving a 50-ohm match at the end of a 300-foot RG-11 run. The author describes a precise VNA-based radial trimming procedure, achieving resonant values within a 3 KHz range. The content emphasizes the practical application of theoretical antenna principles, particularly concerning the interaction between the vertical element, cap hats, and the matching network. It offers a candid assessment of component selection, such as using junkbox parts and acknowledging the need for future upgrades to static drain resistors. The article serves as a comprehensive case study for advanced antenna builders tackling multi-band vertical designs.
-
Optimizing a G5RV or ZS6BKW multiband wire antenna for HF operation often involves addressing common SWR issues and understanding feedline characteristics. This resource chronicles the construction and performance evaluation of a G5RV, initially built for 80m, 40m, 15m, and 10m bands, by a newly licensed Foundation operator. The author details the selection of materials, including 3.5 mm stainless steel wire for the doublet arms and enameled copper wire for the open-wire feeder, and the initial decision to omit a balun based on common online information. The narrative highlights the initial disappointing performance, characterized by high receive noise and poor signal reports on 80 meters, despite the transceiver's internal ATU achieving a 1:1 match. This led to experimentation with a coax current balun and further research into G5RV myths, such as SWR claims and the necessity of a balun. The author then describes modifying the antenna to the ZS6BKW configuration, which involves specific changes to the doublet and feedline lengths, and integrating a 1:1 current balun wound on a ferrite toroid. The modifications resulted in improved reception and transmit performance across the bands.
-
Demonstrates the principles of effective HF multi-band antenna systems, emphasizing the use of non-resonant antennas, understanding line attenuation, and the proper application of transmatches and baluns. The resource challenges prevalent amateur radio myths, such as the necessity of a 1:1 SWR at the antenna feedpoint and the misconception that reflected power is lost or damages equipment. It cites authorities like Jim Fisk (Ham Radio Magazine) and M. Walter Maxwell (W2U, QST's "Another Look At Reflections" series) to support its arguments, providing historical context and technical explanations for these long-held beliefs. The article details how to combine non-resonant antennas with appropriate feedlines and matching devices to achieve broad-band operation. It compares coaxial cable losses with those of balanced open-wire lines, illustrating how ladder line can significantly reduce attenuation and handle higher impedances, enabling an 80-meter dipole to operate effectively across multiple HF bands. Practical guidance is offered on transmatch operation, explaining impedance matching principles and debunking the idea that tuners merely "fool" the transmitter. It also clarifies the function and potential misapplication of baluns, particularly transformer-type baluns, in the presence of high SWR.
-
The folded dipole antenna, often claimed to offer increased bandwidth and a close match to 300-ohm line, is examined in detail. This analysis challenges several prevalent myths, including the assertion that a folded dipole inherently provides wider bandwidth than a thin wire dipole on a single band. The article clarifies that any bandwidth improvement primarily results from the antenna's increased thickness, not from stub effects, folding, or higher feedline impedance. It also addresses the misconception that a folded dipole is an effective multiband antenna, explaining its poor performance on even harmonics where it presents a near dead short. Further discussion refutes the idea that SWR variations are less with changes in antenna length or frequency compared to a regular coax-fed dipole. The resource demonstrates that SWR variations are essentially similar, with folded dipole impedance ranging from approximately 200 to 300 ohms, leading to comparable SWR levels. It also corrects the belief that balanced line feed inherently offers low loss at high SWR, emphasizing that loss is primarily related to the physical characteristics of the transmission line rather than its balanced nature. Modeling results are presented, comparing a folded dipole with 300-ohm and 200-ohm feed lines against regular dipoles fed with 50-ohm and 75-ohm coaxial cable, and a single #14 insulated wire dipole. The data shows negligible differences in 2:1 VSWR bandwidth between folded and regular dipole systems when effective wire diameter is constant, reinforcing the argument that thickness is the dominant factor in bandwidth.