Search results
Query: antenna comparison
Links: 80 | Categories: 3
-
The "Mighty-Wide" six-meter dipole antenna, constructed from 300-ohm ribbon cable, features a total radiating element length of 2794 millimeters. It incorporates two shorting links placed 220 millimeters from each end and a 30 picofarad ceramic trimmer capacitor for impedance matching. The 50-ohm coaxial feedline connects 292 millimeters below the trimmer capacitor, eliminating the need for an external antenna tuning unit. This design provides a wide bandwidth from 50.00 to 52.00 MHz, making it suitable for the entire UK six-meter band allocation. Performance comparisons with a traditional coaxial dipole show superior **Standing Wave Ratio** (SWR) across the 50-52 MHz range, maintaining a low SWR without significant variation after initial adjustment at 51.00 MHz. The antenna's lightweight construction makes it ideal for **loft-mounted** or portable applications, and its folded dipole characteristics contribute to its wideband operation. The design is being considered for rescaling to WARC bands (12 and 17 meters) and 10 meters.
-
Details the construction of a J-vertical antenna specifically for the 10-meter band, offering a practical alternative to a _Slim Jim_ design for 28 MHz. The resource outlines the use of aluminum tubing for the half-wave vertical section and coaxial cable for the quarter-wave matching section, providing specific calculations for element lengths based on frequency and coaxial cable velocity factor. It contrasts the performance of the J-vertical with center-fed dipoles and end-fed verticals, noting superior results in previous comparisons. The article further presents a more recent iteration of the J-vertical, constructed using a fiberglass pole and insulated wire, with updated dimensions for 28.8 MHz. It includes practical advice on weatherproofing connections and securing the antenna for durability against adverse conditions, referencing the survival of an original _J Vertical_ during 110 MPH winds in 1987. The SWR performance is reported as 1.1:1 at 28.6 MHz, maintaining below 1.5:1 across 28.3 to 29 MHz.
-
EH antenna for 160 mt: my experiment and comparison with a short vertical. with full details on construction procedure and testing.
-
Optimizing the impedance transformation and common-mode current suppression in antenna systems often involves selecting an appropriate balun. This project presents a **hybrid balun** design, combining characteristics of both voltage and current baluns to achieve superior performance, particularly when used with an antenna tuner. The design addresses issues like **common-mode current** on the feedline, which can distort the antenna's radiation pattern and introduce RFI in the shack. The construction details include winding techniques for the toroid core, component selection, and practical considerations for integration into an existing antenna system. Performance comparisons are drawn against conventional balun types, highlighting the hybrid balun's effectiveness across the HF bands. The resource provides insights into the current distribution and impedance matching properties, crucial for efficient power transfer and reduced SWR.
-
The HB9ABX RoomCap antenna document details the construction and performance characteristics of a compact HF antenna design. It presents a series of comparative field tests conducted between July and September 2005, evaluating the HB9ABX antenna against established designs like the Microvert MV-500, Cushcraft R5/R7000 verticals, and a 5-element DJ2UT Yagi beam. Specific test scenarios include mobile installations, rooftop deployments, and comparisons on 20m, 40m, 80m, and 160m bands, with signal reports from various European and DX stations. The resource emphasizes the antenna's small physical footprint and its claimed efficiency across multiple HF bands. Test results consistently show the HB9ABX antenna performing comparably to, and often outperforming, larger reference antennas in terms of received signal strength, with reported differences of 1 to 2 S-points (6-12 dB) in many contacts. Notably, a 20m DX test on July 26, 2005, indicated the 1.3m HB9ABX radiator yielded 2-3 S-points stronger signals than an R7000 vertical for US DX stations. An August 12, 2005, test on 40m highlighted the HB9ABX's superior signal-to-noise ratio in urban QRM, demonstrating 10-18 dB better performance than an R7000. The document includes specific callsigns, signal reports, and QTHs for each comparison, providing empirical data for the antenna's performance claims.
-
Understanding antenna gain is crucial for optimizing an amateur radio station's performance, particularly when evaluating shortened or compromised antenna designs. This resource provides a simplified explanation of antenna gain, focusing on the concept of _capture area_ to demystify the often-complex mathematical formulas found in antenna theory texts. It contrasts full-size dipoles with shortened versions, illustrating how physical length directly impacts an antenna's ability to intercept or radiate RF energy. The article presents practical examples, such as a 20m dipole with **0 dB/d** gain and a shortened 20m antenna exhibiting **-6 dB** less gain due to reduced capture area. It further details the significant efficiency losses in various shortened ground plane antennas for 40m and 160m, showing how a 40m center-loaded ground plane might only radiate **7%** of input power. These comparisons highlight the trade-offs involved in using physically small antennas and underscore the importance of minimizing coil losses for effective operation.
-
Over 30 distinct shortwave (SW) receiver models are reviewed, offering insights into their performance, features, and user experiences. These evaluations, contributed by readers of the Usenet newsgroup **Rec.radio.shortwave**, cover a wide array of portable and tabletop radios, including popular units like the Grundig YB-400, Sony ICF-SW77, and various Realistic DX series models. Each review details aspects such as frequency range, tuning steps, SSB functionality, antenna performance, and construction quality, often comparing them to other receivers or ham transceivers like the Icom 725. For instance, the Grundig YB-400 review highlights its 144-30000 kHz AM/SSB coverage, direct keypad entry, and 40 station memories, noting its useful narrow bandwidth and tone switch for adjacent signal separation. It also discusses the **SSB mode** stability and the limitations of its 1 kHz frequency resolution for precise zero-beating. The review further details antenna performance, including the effectiveness of the built-in whip, the provided 7m reel antenna, and the potential for overload with larger outdoor antennas. Other reviews delve into specific issues, such as the Sony ICF-SW77's frequency display inaccuracies and timer malfunctions, or the Realistic DX-342's compact size and surprisingly good MW DXing capabilities despite its analog tuning. The collection provides practical, user-generated feedback on sensitivity, selectivity, audio quality, and ergonomic features, helping shortwave listeners understand the real-world performance and quirks of these receivers.
-
The KD6WD Moxon Antenna Project details the construction of 50-ohm two-element wire beam antennas, specifically Moxon rectangles, for the 10, 15, 17, and 20-meter bands. It utilizes AC6LA's software for critical measurement calculations (A-E) based on center frequency and wire size. Construction involves 16-gauge silver-coated copper wire, 16-foot telescoping fiberglass crappie fishing poles as spreaders in an "X" configuration, and various hub designs including aluminum tubing or PVC joints. A 1:1 current balun is used at the feedpoint, with wire nuts for connections, often achieving a 1:1 SWR across the design band. The project highlights practical applications, such as running a kilowatt into the antennas for greyline DX contacts, consistently yielding excellent signal reports. Comparisons to quad loops show 4 to 5 S-unit improvements in both receive and transmit. The Moxon design, according to L.B. Cebik's analysis, offers superior forward gain and front-to-back ratio among wire beams. The author notes a "DX-Vane" effect where a freely suspended Moxon automatically points to the strongest DX signal. Attempts at dual-band operation (17/20 meters) with a single feed were unsuccessful, reinforcing the Moxon's monoband nature, with EZNEC plots provided for a 17-meter Moxon at 30 feet.
-
Over 40 years of experience inform the reviews and commentary presented on Dave's Radio Receiver Page, covering a wide array of radio receivers and transceivers. The resource details specific models such as the **ICOM IC-R8600** SDR Communications Receiver, which is lauded as Icom's best wide-band receiver, even surpassing the IC-R9500 in performance. Other notable reviews include the ICOM IC-7300 HF Transceiver, highlighting its direct sampling SDR technology and spectrum scope capabilities, alongside numerous models from Japan Radio Co. (JRC), Kenwood, Yaesu, and various portable shortwave receivers. The content provides practical insights into the performance and characteristics of each radio, often drawing comparisons between models. For instance, the early issues with the AOR AR7030 receiver's Bourns mechanical encoders are thoroughly documented, including AOR's eventual switch to higher-quality Alps encoders. The page also features reviews of antennas like the MFJ-1026 Noise Canceling Signal Enhancer and various power supplies, offering a holistic view of radio monitoring setups. The author's "2 ear / 2 eye method" emphasizes real-world listening experiences over laboratory measurements, providing a unique perspective on equipment utility.
-
Article and comparison between bazooka antennas and dipole, taking care of effieciency and bandwidth
-
Examines the rationale behind L. B. Cebik, W4RNL's, consistent use of dBi for specifying antenna gain in his modeling work, contrasting it with the common practice of using dBd. The article meticulously defines decibels as relative power measurements and introduces the theoretical _isotropic radiator_ as the baseline for dBi, highlighting its utility as an unchanging constant for universal antenna comparison. It details how maximum gain in dBi allows for straightforward numerical comparisons between antennas, while also emphasizing the importance of considering other factors like horizontal beamwidth, vertical beamwidth, and elevation angle of maximum radiation for a complete performance picture. The resource then critically analyzes the concept of dBd, categorizing it into _dBd-I_ (ideal dipole), _dBd-RM_ (real modeled dipole), and _dBd-RR_ (real range dipole), exposing the ambiguities and inconsistencies inherent in these varied definitions. W4RNL argues that the lack of standardized protocols for dBd measurements, particularly in real-world test ranges, makes direct comparisons problematic without extensive supplementary data on test conditions and comparison antennas. He illustrates how these complexities often obscure rather than clarify antenna performance. Ultimately, the article advocates for dBi as the more robust and unambiguous standard for antenna modelers, especially when comparing diverse antenna types where a dipole is not a relevant benchmark. It acknowledges that range testers may continue to use dBd-RR due to practical limitations, but stresses the critical need for detailed test protocols to ensure meaningful results. The discussion underscores the ongoing challenge of correlating real-world antenna measurements with theoretical modeling.
-
Presents Mr. Coily, a manufacturer specializing in custom-built base and mobile antennas for amateur radio and CB applications. The product line features unique coil designs, including single, double, and triple coil configurations, alongside flat coil options. Dan is listed as the contact for inquiries regarding these specialized antenna solutions. The resource highlights custom ball mounts as an accessory, indicating a focus on tailored installations. While specific technical specifications or performance comparisons are not detailed, the emphasis on custom builds suggests a service catering to operators seeking bespoke antenna solutions for their particular station or mobile setup.
-
W1ZY's 40-meter **Moxon** antenna project details nine months of experimentation, culminating in a reversible array built from No. 12 insulated wire. The design incorporates two RF current baluns and a unique two-wire element construction, where each element consists of two parallel wires spaced 3 inches apart. The resource provides specific dimensions for the first prototype, including A=50.98', B=7.87', C=1.25', D=9.3', and E=18.42', optimized for 7.050 MHz CW operation. It thoroughly explains the construction of custom two-wire insulators from Plexiglas semi-rods and the critical pre-tensioning process required to maintain wire separation and array integrity. The author, Bill, emphasizes the antenna's exceptional receive performance, noting a 30-35 dB front-to-back ratio, which allows for significant signal rejection from the rear. While the Moxon offers 5-6 dB gain on transmit, its primary advantage lies in its ability to radically reduce rear-facing signals on receive, a characteristic Bill believes is often overlooked in transmit-focused comparisons. The guide details a flexible tuning method using removable tail-end jumpers, enabling adjustments to both tail-end and parallel dimensions without re-soldering the feed point, a technique refined over three prototypes.
-
For radio amateurs seeking compact, directional antenna solutions, the Moxon Rectangle offers an attractive alternative to traditional two-element Yagis. This resource compiles several articles by L. B. Cebik, W4RNL, exploring the **Moxon Rectangle** design, which provides gain comparable to a full-size two-element array but with a significantly improved **front-to-back ratio** and a direct 50-Ohm feedpoint match. The collection covers both wire arrays, particularly for lower HF bands, and rotatable aluminum beam constructions, addressing various aspects of this popular antenna configuration. The articles delve into specific band applications, including designs for 10 meters, 40 meters, and 2 meters, alongside discussions on multi-banding techniques and pattern characteristics. Comparisons are drawn between the Moxon and other antenna types, such as VK2ABQ Squares, highlighting the Moxon's advantages in terms of size and performance. Practical construction notes are provided for both wire and aluminum versions, offering insights into building these antennas for different operating environments.
-
Comparison chart between Cushcraft R8, Hy-Gain AV640 , Butternut HF6V, Gap Titan and Eco 7+
-
Animated quad and yagi comparison. You can see antennas' characteristics behavior in a vertical plane with changing of the height.
-
Testing and comparison of traps and trap antennas
-
ERP Calculator is an Amateur Radio software utility designed to perform a side-by-side comparison of two Ham Radio antenna systems. ERP Calculator comes pre-programmed with data files including published data for several popular brands and types of coax cable as well as several popular antenna system brands and models. ERP Calculator displays values of ERP, Antenna Power Gain, Antenna Feed point Power, Antenna System Gain in dB, Antenna Gain in dBd, SWR Attenuation in dB, SWR Power Attenuation, Coax Loss in dB, and Coax Power Loss
-
A ranking of receiving antennas based on noise being evenly distributed in all directions. These rankings are most accurate in the frequency range of AM broadcast, 160 or 80 meter bands
-
The ZS6BKW wire antenna, a variant of the G5RV, utilizes a specific 13m (42.6 ft) length of 450-ohm window line as its matching section, feeding a 28.5m (93.5 ft) flat-top element. This design aims for lower SWR on 40m, 20m, 17m, 12m, and 10m compared to a standard G5RV, often achieving SWR values below 1.5:1 on these bands without an antenna tuner. The feedpoint impedance transformation provided by the window line allows for direct connection to 50-ohm coax on multiple bands. F4FHH's experience involved constructing the ZS6BKW and evaluating its performance against an _OCF dipole_ (Off-Center Fed) on various HF frequencies. The article includes observations on SWR readings and operational effectiveness, highlighting the ZS6BKW's suitability for multi-band operation. The antenna's overall length, including the flat-top and window line, is approximately **41.5 meters** (136 feet), making it a significant wire antenna for fixed station use. Comparative analysis with the OCF dipole provided practical insights into the ZS6BKW's advantages and limitations, particularly concerning bandwidth and tuner requirements.
-
The resource provides an in-depth analysis of the W6NL 40m _Moxon Yagi_ antenna, utilizing a NEC-2 model to simulate its performance. It details the antenna's design parameters, including element lengths and spacing, and explores critical operational aspects such as feedpoint impedance, SWR across the 40-meter band, and radiation patterns. The document systematically presents the model's setup and the methodology for evaluating the antenna's behavior in different environments, including free space and over real ground. Performance data derived from the NEC-2 model illustrates the antenna's forward gain, front-to-back ratio, and beamwidth. For instance, the model predicts a free-space gain of approximately **6.5 dBi** and a front-to-back ratio exceeding **20 dB** at resonance. Comparisons are drawn between free-space performance and operation at various heights above average ground, demonstrating the impact of ground proximity on take-off angle and overall efficiency. The analysis also touches upon the antenna's bandwidth characteristics, indicating its suitability for the entire 40-meter band with acceptable SWR.
-
Operating a ZS6BKW antenna often involves understanding its lineage from the _G5RV_ design, with specific modifications by ZS6BKW to optimize performance on several bands. Through computational analysis and field measurements, the antenna's dimensions were refined to allow operation on 10, 12, 17, 20, and 40 meters without an antenna tuner. For 80, 30, and 15 meters, a tuner is necessary, though efficiency on 30 and 15 meters is noted as not particularly high. The physical configuration consists of two 13.755-meter radiating elements fed by a 12.20-meter section of 450-ohm ladder line. Tuning the antenna on the 20-meter band is critical, and any deviation in the ladder line's characteristic impedance necessitates recalculating the element lengths. The design is also referenced in the 12th edition of _Rothammel's Antennenbuch_, page 219. Proper common mode current suppression is crucial at the transition from ladder line to coaxial cable. This can be achieved with a common mode choke, such as several turns of coax wound into a coil or over a ferrite toroid like an Amidon T130. While a 1:1 balun is an option, it may introduce issues.
-
The "REAL TIME ANTENNA GAIN COMPARATOR SYSTEM" by IK0BDO details a low-budget amateur radio tool designed for optimizing homebrew VHF/UHF antennas. It facilitates the simultaneous comparison of two antennas, one a known reference (e.g., a dipole) and the other under test, displaying their relative gain directly in decibels. The system addresses limitations of previous measurement benches by enabling on-field optimization, accounting for balun performance, impedance mismatching, and cable losses. The core of the device is an electronic solid-state switch utilizing PIN diodes, which alternates signal sampling from the two antennas 100 times per second. This rapid switching prevents the receiver's Automatic Gain Control (AGC) from compensating for signal differences, allowing for precise comparative measurements. The document includes detailed schematic diagrams for both the RF switching unit and the associated measure unit, which employs two VU-meters to display cyclic signal levels. It also provides guidance on setting up the PIN diode switching with an oscilloscope and adjusting trimmer potentiometers P1, P2, and P3 for optimal operation. Further sections cover the construction of VHF (144.150 KHz) and UHF (432.360 MHz) beacons for testing, along with critical considerations for selecting an appropriate test range or site. Recommendations include maintaining a minimum distance of 50 wavelengths between transmitting and receiving positions, avoiding ground reflections, and using reference antennas with gains similar to the antenna under examination. The author notes satisfactory results from measurements on dipoles and other antennas, highlighting the system's ability to appreciate fractional decibel differences.
-
-
The **70cm Moxon Beam** project outlines the construction and testing of a compact, directional antenna for the 432 MHz band. G3XBM recounts his early 1980s experience with a 4W FM321 transceiver and a Jaybeam 48-element TV antenna, which provided a baseline for his later UHF antenna experiments. This project focuses on a simpler, yet effective, design for local and regional contacts, emphasizing ease of construction and practical field results over complex theory. The article details the specific dimensions and materials used for the Moxon rectangle, including 6mm diameter aluminum tubing for the elements and a PVC boom. G3XBM notes that the antenna was built for portable use, making it lightweight and easily deployable for field operations. The feedpoint impedance was measured at 50 ohms, ensuring a direct match without the need for an external tuner, which simplifies setup. Performance tests included comparisons against a commercial 5-element Yagi, revealing that the Moxon provided comparable forward gain and an excellent front-to-back ratio, crucial for reducing local QRM. The author's observations confirm the Moxon's reputation as a robust performer for its size, suitable for both fixed and portable 70cm operations.
-
Presents a construction project for a linear-loaded 40-meter rotatable dipole, detailing the design evolution from mid-element coils to 300-ohm twinlead loading. It covers material selection, including repurposed fishing poles and EMT conduit, and outlines the assembly process for the antenna elements and mounting plate. The resource provides specific measurements for element lengths and linear loading sections, along with SWR plots demonstrating the antenna's resonance at 7.035 MHz with a 1.1:1 SWR, and bandwidth up to 7.120 MHz below 2:1 SWR. The article documents the antenna's performance during various RTTY and CW contests, including the SARTG RTTY and SCC RTTY contests in August 2006, and the ARRL DX CW and CQWW WPX RTTY contests in February 2007. It reports successful operation at 500-1000W, noting improved performance after replacing a faulty coax cable. Specific DX contacts from British Columbia, including stations in Europe and South Africa, are listed, illustrating the antenna's capability despite its shortened length and relatively low height of 55 feet. The content highlights practical considerations such as weatherproofing the connections and supporting the fiberglass elements to prevent sagging. It also includes a brief comparison to an inverted-V at similar height and a ground-mounted vertical, noting the rotatable dipole's quieter reception. The author shares insights into the iterative design process and tuning adjustments made to achieve optimal resonance.
-
Review by G3TXQ and comparison to its modificated versions. SWR Measurements on inverted V setup and comparison from EZNEC model and a real one.
-
Quad and loop antennas comparisons, evaluating the impedance and gain of both antennas and considerationso n horizontal loop antennas for low bands by PA0FRI
-
Comparison chart for low-band receiving antennas
-
Comparison of 50 and 70 Mhz antennas, commercial and home made projects
-
-
The _National Contest Journal_ (NCJ) serves as a dedicated resource for amateur radio contesters, providing in-depth articles, operational strategies, and technical insights. Published bimonthly by the ARRL, it covers a wide array of contesting topics, including antenna systems, station optimization, operating techniques, and rule interpretations for major events like the NA Sprint and various QSO Parties. The journal aims to enhance the competitive edge of participants across all skill levels, from casual operators to serious multi-operator teams, by sharing experiences and data from high-scoring stations. NCJ content frequently includes detailed analyses of contest results, offering breakdowns of scores, participant statistics, and comparisons of operating strategies. Readers can find practical advice on improving their contest performance, such as optimizing logging software usage or maximizing **run rates**. The journal also features columns on specific contest modes like RTTY and provides updates on rule changes and upcoming events, helping contesters prepare for future competitions and achieve better results, often leading to **top 10** finishes in their respective categories.
-
What is an EWE Antenna, comparisons, performance and homebrew plan
-
This article compares two commercial vertical antennas for the 4-meter amateur radio band: the Watson WVB-70 half-wave and the Sirio CX4-71. The Watson measures 2.03m in length, costs around £40, and exhibited adequate performance but required additional waterproofing after rain affected its VSWR readings. The longer Sirio CX4-71 (3.02m) performed noticeably better, delivering signals approximately 2 S-points stronger than the Watson. The Sirio demonstrated high build quality, a stable 1.2-1.4:1 VSWR, and weather resilience, though minor VSWR fluctuations were observed during rain and frost. Both antennas are half-wave designs requiring no ground plane radials.
-
A very interesting blog article on a real world comparison on the popular multiband wire antenna, the G5RV, by Bob Raynor N4JTE
-
A comparison of multiband dipoles, including jumpered dipole versus fan dipole antennas, dipole fed by ladder line, resonant dipoles antennas. ARRL lab notes
-
Examines the historical role of telegraphy within Canadian railway operations, detailing the evolution of communication systems crucial for train dispatch and coordination. It covers the technical substance of railway telegraphy, including equipment, operational procedures, and the personnel involved, such as agents and operators. The resource provides insights into the **F59PH locomotive** history, development, and components, alongside diagrams of various parts like antennae and traction motors. The content also explores the practical application of these systems by documenting specific railway events, such as the CPR Galt Sub operations from 1895-1971 and GO Transit's operational history. It includes photo galleries, schematics, and diagrams of locomotives and cab cars, offering a visual and technical comparison of different railway equipment. The site also features information on **GO Transit** rolling stock, including MP40s and commuter coaches, providing a historical context for railway communication and transportation.
-
Delta loop antennas for 40 meters plans and comparison of some models
-
The HF horizontal loop has been around for many years now. This article includes a YouTube video and discusses the reasons for looking at this antenna, its design, and its installation. There are some on-air comparisons against three regular double bazooka (coax) dipoles and the Par SWL End-Fed antenna.
-
Testing performances of indoor antenna. A comparison of a magnetic loop antenna vs a classic wire dipole done using wsprlite on 30 meters band.
-
G/T (Gain-to-Noise Temperature) is a critical figure of merit for evaluating the receive performance of VHF/UHF antennas, particularly for weak-signal work like EME (Earth-Moon-Earth) or meteor scatter. This resource presents extensive simulation data for numerous 2-meter and 6-meter Yagi antenna designs, originally compiled by _VE7BQH_ (Lance Johnson). The lists, updated as of October 2017, include various antenna models from designers such as _DK7ZB_, G0KSC, and K1FO, providing key performance parameters. Each entry details the antenna's G/T value, gain, front-to-back ratio, beamwidth, and VSWR at specific frequencies like 144.1 MHz or 145.0 MHz. The data facilitates comparison of different Yagi configurations, including those with folded dipoles and varying intrinsic impedances, aiding radio amateurs in selecting optimal antennas for their specific operational needs on the 2-meter and 6-meter bands.
-
The **136kHz Vertical Antenna** at G3YMC employs a Butternut HF2V structure, standing 10m tall. It integrates a 6.5mH loading coil to achieve resonance, with a matching transformer for impedance adjustment. The antenna's configuration includes top loading via a 12m horizontal wire, enhancing capacitive impedance. Initial measurements indicated a high impedance of around 300 ohms, necessitating a transformer for a 50-ohm match. Despite challenges with ground losses, the vertical antenna has shown improved performance in specific directions, filling nulls present in the previous loop antenna setup. The tuning remains broad, with variations due to environmental factors affecting the matching. Ongoing adjustments and comparisons with the loop antenna will continue to refine its effectiveness.
-
The .64 wavelength antenna is presented as a single-element design offering superior gain, specifically noted for achieving at least 0.8 dB/d more gain towards the horizon compared to a 5/8 wave element. The discussion emphasizes identifying specific hardware revisions, defining clear operating goals for various signal paths like receiving, transmitting, and data, and establishing a baseline measurement before any modifications. This methodical approach ensures accurate assessment of antenna performance. Practical application involves a structured testing methodology where only one variable is altered at a time to ensure valid comparisons. The article suggests exploring related technical paths, referencing components like the R820T Rafael Micro and Mirics MSI3101 SDR USB Dongle, and encourages a holistic view of the radio system from antenna to operator. This systematic process helps hams optimize their antenna systems for improved DXing and contesting.
-
During a club's "Filetto Day" event, a comparative field test was conducted between a **Buddipole** antenna and a homemade 20/40-meter wire dipole. The author, IW5EDI, performed this personal evaluation from a mountain top at 1500 meters above sea level, utilizing a Yaesu FT-857D transceiver to switch between antennas. The observations on the 20-meter band indicated that the wire dipole consistently delivered significantly stronger signals compared to the Buddipole. Additionally, the Buddipole exhibited higher levels of **QRM** during the listening tests. The commercial Buddipole, known for its multiband capability and compact size with a self-supporting tripod, was contrasted with the simpler, larger wire dipole, which required a fiberglass fish pole for support. This direct comparison highlights practical differences in performance and deployment between a popular portable commercial antenna and a basic wire antenna in a real-world operating environment.
-
The Buddipole Deluxe, a portable HF/VHF antenna system, receives a practical assessment from IW5EDI after a month of field use. The author, constrained by antenna restrictions, highlights the system's crucial role in enabling portable operations, even managing sporadic digital activity from a balcony. Direct comparisons to a fixed 3-band dipole reveal surprisingly comparable signal reports on 15, 17, and 20 meters, underscoring the Buddipole's effectiveness in real-world scenarios. Tuning the Buddipole proves straightforward on bands down to 20 meters, though the review notes significant challenges with SWR on lower bands like 40 meters, where achieving better than 3:1 SWR was problematic. Observations also include SWR variations with dipole rotation and mast height, suggesting environmental factors play a role. The overall manufacturing quality of the antenna and its accessories, including the tripod and carry bag, is deemed good, despite a minor issue with a pole connector. Looking ahead, the author plans to construct a homemade Buddipole version, possibly optimized for the 30-meter band, specifically for PSK31 operations from an apartment. This personal project reflects a common amateur radio practice of adapting commercial designs for specific needs, further extending the utility of portable antenna concepts.
-
The M0PLK multiband delta loop antenna project details the construction of a non-resonant, bidirectional antenna designed for 20-10m operation, requiring an external antenna tuner. The design utilizes two 5.65m aluminum tubes arranged at right angles, with 2x 2.80m antenna wires converging into a 2.30m ladder line, feeding a 1:4 balun. The resource provides a comprehensive parts list, including specific dimensions for aluminum tubes (25mm, 20mm, 16mm outer diameter), DX-Wire FS2, and custom 3D-printed components like a middle insulator, tube end caps, and ladder line spacers, with STL files provided. Construction steps cover base plate fabrication from a 300x300x4mm aluminum sheet, balun assembly, tube preparation with slits and threaded holes, and wire attachment with strain relief. Initial VSWR measurements are presented, indicating performance in line with expectations across the target bands. The author reports successful SSB test QSOs to the USA on 10, 12, 15, 17, and 20m immediately after completion. The project highlights the antenna's bidirectional pattern, noting the need for a lightweight, remote-controlled rotator to fully utilize its directional capabilities. Comparisons are drawn to the Cobweb antenna, with the M0PLK design cited for its reduced local QRM pickup. The article references external sources, including M0AWS's detailed report and PC modeling, along with other construction variants and commercial assembly instructions, providing a robust foundation for replication.
-
Constructing a compact directional antenna for the 17-meter band, this resource details the build process for a Moxon rectangle, a two-element Yagi variant with folded-back elements. It covers the antenna's evolution from the _VK2ABQ beam_ and provides specific dimensions for a version built using fishing pole whips. The content includes a discussion of the antenna's radiation pattern, feedpoint impedance, and its inherent front-to-back ratio, which is often superior to a standard two-element Yagi. Practical considerations for element spacing and material choices are also addressed, alongside a visual representation of the antenna's physical layout. Performance data presented includes a comparison showing the Moxon rectangle's **2.5 dB gain** over a half-wave dipole and a front-to-back ratio of **20 dB**. The resource also touches upon the antenna's relatively wide bandwidth for a two-element beam and its suitability for portable operations due to its compact footprint. It offers insights into optimizing the design for specific operating conditions and discusses the advantages of its lower take-off angle compared to omnidirectional wire antennas, making it effective for DX contacts on the 17-meter band.
-
A 102-inch vertical whip, commonly a CB antenna, forms the core of this low-profile 10-meter antenna design, optimized for the 28 MHz band. The construction details specify three 8-foot radials made from scrap wire, connected to a common point. This simple yet effective setup is designed for ease of construction and deployment, making it accessible for operators with limited space or materials. The design emphasizes using readily available components, including PVC pipe for the mast and a SO-239 connector for the feedline, ensuring a straightforward build process for a resonant quarter-wave vertical. Field results indicate that this antenna provides good performance for local and DX contacts on 10 meters, despite its compact footprint. The author, N8WRL, shares practical insights into its construction and tuning, highlighting its suitability for temporary or permanent installations where a full-sized antenna might be impractical. Comparisons to more complex designs suggest that this low-profile vertical offers a respectable signal-to-noise ratio and effective radiated power for its size, proving that simple designs can yield satisfying on-air results.
-
Two different ways to create autotransformer for end fed half wave wire antennas, by using ferrite or air core.
-
Evaluates the **LDG Z100 autotuner**, a device designed to automatically match antenna impedance for optimal transmission efficiency. The review discusses its performance in comparison to the MFJ-902, noting that while the Z100 is a reliable autotuner, it does not match the range of impedances that the MFJ-902 can handle. The Z100 is suitable for operators seeking a 100-watt autotuner that covers HF bands, providing a practical solution for those who require automatic tuning without manual adjustments. The review highlights the Z100's operational context, focusing on its use in HF bands and its practical application in amateur radio setups. While it offers a straightforward tuning process, the Z100's limitations in impedance matching are noted, making it less versatile than some competitors. This comparison provides valuable insights for operators considering an upgrade or replacement for their current autotuner. The Z100's performance is positioned within the broader market of autotuners, offering a clear perspective on its strengths and weaknesses in real-world amateur radio operations.